Summary of facts: The Archdiocese of Oklahoma City sought to open a virtual charter school, St. Isidore of Seville, to serve rural areas and underserved communities and families. The Oklahoma charter school board approved its application. Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond then sued St. Isidore and the state charter school board, seeking to block the school from opening on the grounds that the school is a state actor and since it is faith-based it violates the Establishment Clause. Moreover, the attorney general made numerous public statements to the effect that blocking St. Isidore was necessary to prevent Islamic schools from receiving state charters. The charter school board and St. Isidore argued that it is not a state actor but merely a state contractor. The Oklahoma Supreme Court sided with the attorney general and the board and the school are now seeking review of that decision in the U.S. Supreme Court.
RFI position: RFI filed two separate amicus briefs in the Supreme Court in support of St. Isidore’s petition for review. The first argues that the Supreme Court of Oklahoma’s holding that religious charter schools violate the Establishment Clause cannot be squared with the Free Exercise Clause, which forbids the states from excluding religious persons from access to public benefits on the basis of their religious use of those benefits. Moreover, the court below incorrectly labeled St. Isidore a state actor because it had a contract with the state. This error threatens religious institutions, which frequently contract with governments at all levels to provide social services. The second brief, a multifaith brief joined by RFI’s Islam and Religious Freedom Action Team, argues that the Oklahoma Attorney General evinced hostility toward religious minorities by repeatedly demeaning Islam and other minority faiths, tainting his official actions and rendering them invalid under the First Amendment.
Read the RFI amicus brief here and the RFI Islam Team brief here.
THE RFI BLOG
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/434ec/434ec14237b7fdeb82bac518c49e21e7c1d92080" alt="Featured image for “Following Quran Burnings, Will Sweden Stumble Into Anti-Blasphemy Laws?”"
Following Quran Burnings, Will Sweden Stumble Into Anti-Blasphemy Laws?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a7fae/a7fae3a56216326a741e533fa0fefb80b1f9a1dc" alt="Featured image for “RFI President Speaks at the Religious Freedom in America Conference”"
RFI President Speaks at the Religious Freedom in America Conference
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8040e/8040efd5e81ea7987686a82e62ba5434b4f5f805" alt="Featured image for “RFI Highlights from the 2025 IRF Summit”"
RFI Highlights from the 2025 IRF Summit
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9fe34/9fe34582003981c35e4a94a98360ab33890c7a9f" alt="Featured image for “Emerging Tech and Religious Freedom”"
Emerging Tech and Religious Freedom
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/96872/96872aace3df5aa13581ed64721f16f6ce945e9e" alt="Featured image for “RFI Participates in Summit on Post-Election Trends, Hopes, and Challenges for Faith-Based Service Organizations”"
RFI Participates in Summit on Post-Election Trends, Hopes, and Challenges for Faith-Based Service Organizations
CORNERSTONE FORUM
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cc108/cc108ca70b8eb041bdc8872913340eed6277a6a7" alt="Featured image for “Reaffirming Religious Freedom: Bridging U.S. Advocacy and Iraq’s Constitutional Framework”"
Reaffirming Religious Freedom: Bridging U.S. Advocacy and Iraq’s Constitutional Framework
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ff896/ff89673162c5e6b6d0db3df4db6dff3bd1c3168f" alt="Featured image for “Political Polarization, Same-Sex Marriage and Religious Liberty”"
Political Polarization, Same-Sex Marriage and Religious Liberty
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cc108/cc108ca70b8eb041bdc8872913340eed6277a6a7" alt="Featured image for “Bridging the Gap Between International Efforts and Local Realities: Advancing Religious Freedom in the MENA Region”"
Bridging the Gap Between International Efforts and Local Realities: Advancing Religious Freedom in the MENA Region
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cc108/cc108ca70b8eb041bdc8872913340eed6277a6a7" alt="Featured image for “Challenges to Religious Freedom in Iraq and the Critical Need for Action”"
Challenges to Religious Freedom in Iraq and the Critical Need for Action
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c1f26/c1f265df1d674812ce156b59f5c5036a3148bc57" alt="Featured image for “Public Bioethics & the Failure of Expressive Individualism”"