Summary of facts: A chaplain at Faith Bible Chapel, a Colorado church, allegedly delivered an overly-political sermon on race and then behaved divisively in the ensuing controversy. The chaplain then left the church and sued the church in federal court. The church argued that the suit should be dismissed under the First Amendment’s “ministerial exception,” which bars government interference in church leadership decisions . The district court, treating the church’s ministerial exception argument separately from the former chaplain’s substantive claims, ruled that the exception did not apply in this case. The church appealed, arguing that the ministerial exception rendered it immune to suit. The US Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit ruled that the ministerial exception is not a jurisdictional bar to suit, and that the lower court’s decision could not be appealed until after trial on the merits of the former chaplain’s claims. Faith Bible Chapel has asked the Supreme Court to review that decision. (This is a companion case to Synod of Bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia v. Belya).
RFI’s position: The religion clauses of the First Amendment prohibit the government from interfering with the leadership decisions of religious institutions. Courts do not have the constitutional authority to entertain lawsuits regarding their employment practices. The ministerial exception is therefore analogous to qualified immunity, and whether it applies in a given case is a legal question. The Supreme Court should grant review to settle a split among the federal courts of appeals on this issue.
Read the amicus brief here.
THE RFI BLOG

RFI President Gives Distinguished Reich Lecture at U.S. Air Force Academy

RFI’s Nathaniel Hurd and Andrew Kubick Interviewed on Religious Freedom’s Deepest Questions

Religious Freedom Failures in Algeria Must Be Addressed

RFI President Eric Patterson: “Niger, Coups, and Violence in West Africa”

RFI Champions Rights of Muslim and Christian Parents, Files Amicus Brief in Fourth Circuit
CORNERSTONE FORUM

Public Bioethics & the Failure of Expressive Individualism

Religious Liberty in American Higher Education

Scotland’s Kate Forbes and the March of Secularism

70 Years of Religious Freedom in Sweden: Prospects and Challenges
